A survivor, chang'aa den, West Karateng assistant chief Fred Odhiambo and Nina Masore from Equality Now

Every night, *Akinyi’s daughter (not her real name) would leave home while her youngest child was still breastfeeding, entrusting the baby to her grandmother’s care until morning.

She was barely 17 when poverty and the influence of friends drew her into a chang’aa den, where she was introduced to a practice known as ‘papasa’, a trade in which men paid as little as Sh20 to touch young girls in the Nametsa area in Kisumu West.She dropped out of school, became a mother of two, contracted HIV and later died after her health deteriorated, leaving her elderly mother to raise the children she left behind.Today, the mother carries the pain of losing her daughter while watching her grandchildren struggle with the same poverty she believes pushed their mother into the chang’aa den.

“Touching the girls from the neck to their breasts, they charge Sh20. Going down to the thighs is Sh50, and down further the whole body goes at Sh200 and might even extend to sex,” she says.

“This is the business that has been going on; the owners of the local brew gather young girls for such kinds of jobs.”

She was introduced to the practice by a group of friends who, according to her, were “living a careless life”.

“After being exposed to that job, my daughter was damaged beyond words; she stopped going to school, and her health deteriorated until her death. Alcohol has finished our girls around here,” she says.

The mother says the practice not only robbed her daughter of her education but also exposed her to health risks and an environment that eventually changed the course of her life.

It was while living away from her family that she became pregnant and eventually gave birth to two sons.

She was also infected with HIV during this period, the mother says. As her health deteriorated, she returned home, where her mother cared for her.

The loss has left a wound that is difficult to heal, saying she is particularly troubled that ‘papasa’ continues to expose girls in the community to exploitation.

“As a parent, I feel so bad to hear that ‘papasa’ is still going on. I feel pain in my heart because our girls are exposed to such a bad life because of poverty. I questioned God, telling him [I wish] he would let my daughter live so she could take care of her children instead of leaving them with me at this old age,” she says.

Years later, the grandmother is now left to care for the two children, while struggling to provide food and keep them in school.

Despite the hardship, she continues to do whatever she can to ensure her grandchildren remain in school.

But keeping the children in school has come at another cost. With little money to buy food or meet school-related expenses, the family has been forced to turn to charcoal burning as a source of income.

As she raises the two children her daughter left behind, the mother fears that without support and economic opportunities, the same poverty that claimed her daughter could continue shaping the lives of another generation.

COMMUNITY BARAZAS

West Karateng assistant chief Fred Odhiambo says authorities are aware of the ‘papasa’ practice in the villages, but its secretive nature has made it difficult to identify those involved.

He said poverty remains one of the factors driving the practice, adding that local administration officials are using community meetings to raise awareness about its dangers.

Odhiambo said authorities regularly raid chang’aa dens but have not yet established the identities of those involved in the ‘papasa’ trade, making enforcement difficult.

“The ‘papasa’ issue has been ongoing in the villages; it is being done in complete secrecy, and those who want to talk about it are chased from social gatherings,” he said.

“This happens because of poverty in these areas. We cannot deny that the act is not happening. No, it is going on, and our responsibility is to ensure we stop it.”

He also said some villages are hard to reach, making them hard to monitor.

“Accessibility to the villages is poor. The type of terrain, hills and forests around here also adds to the causes,” he said.

“We always follow up on the schoolchildren at the beginning of the year, those who are progressing to another level of schools. We follow up and ensure they are admitted to school.”

Odhiambo said community dialogue would remain central to efforts to address the problem, with regular barazas providing an opportunity for residents to raise concerns.

‘VICTIM OF CIRCUMSTANCES’

While local authorities grapple with the crisis, 23-year-old Mary* (not her real name) from Nametsa village offers a glimpse into how poverty draws young women into sexual exploitation in exchange for money to support their families.

Mary says poverty has pushed her into having sexual relations with men for money to feed her child, ageing mother and younger siblings.

She says the practice is common among girls in the area, with some accepting money for sexual touching, while others give in to sexual advances because of financial hardship.

“In our home, we sell the local brew. When a man comes, and sometimes, they have money, they may have Sh1,000, and they wink at you, saying they will give you a certain amount. You weigh the situation at home, and you end up deciding to sleep with him to get that money to buy food for the family,” Mary says.

She says her first encounter earned her Sh400, prompting her to repeat the act, and she has since had sexual encounters with more than 15 men.

Despite wanting to stop, she says her family’s dependence on her income leaves her with few alternatives.

“As of now, I have to continue with the act because I have a child, my mother is aged, and my siblings look up to me,” she says.

She admits that her mother does not know the source of the money used to help at home.

“I feel bad for engaging in such an act. That is where life’s circumstances have put me. In my heart, I know it is wrong,” she says.

“I would love to stop it even now. I hope to get support to start a business or go back to school. I have studied until college; I pursued IT.”

UNENFORCED LAWS

Kisumu Medical and Education Trust policy and advocacy lead Sharon Amendi says community dialogues have helped expose cases of sexual and gender-based violence that would otherwise remain hidden.

She says one of the emerging concerns in Kisumu West is the sexual exploitation of girls in chang’aa dens, where children are reportedly subjected to touching and defilement in exchange for small amounts of money.

“In Kisumu West, we have seen the issue of women, especially mothers, giving out their children to be defiled in exchange for money for as low as Sh20 by men in the community. This especially happens in chang’aa dens,” Amendi says.

She says the practice allegedly involves payments of between Sh20 and Sh50 for touching, while higher amounts are paid for sexual abuse.

“Sh20, Sh50 for touching, then Sh250 for defiling. At the end of the day, they collect all the money and distribute it to the women who engage in such,” she says.

“The action plan is for the police to follow up with the perpetrators and for the chiefs to follow up in the chang’aa dens and have them closed. We also offer psychosocial support to the survivors.”

She says two girls whose cases emerged through their schools have received psychosocial support, while concerns over the alleged involvement of some local administrators were escalated to the Court Users Committee and the Kisumu county commissioner.

Amendi says continued engagement with residents is crucial because sexual exploitation often remains hidden until communities are given a safe space to speak.

Nina Masore, legal adviser at Equality Now under the End Sexual Violence campaign, said ‘papasa’ is sexual exploitation that preys on people made vulnerable by poverty and other social challenges.

She says Kenyan laws criminalise sexual exploitation, but implementation remains a major challenge. She cited the Sexual Offences Act, Children Act and Counter-Trafficking in Persons Act.

“Sexual exploitation is a situation where the dignity, consent and free will of a person is impaired because of them not being able to provide for themselves or to speak out for themselves,” Masore says.

It mostly affects women and girls but sometimes men and boys, too, she says.

“We find that the law sufficiently provides for it as being a crime, but usually the problem is in applying the law.”

Masore says poverty is one of the major factors driving sexual exploitation and calls for greater investment in programmes supporting vulnerable families.

She also says authorities need to tackle the wider networks facilitating the exploitation rather than focusing only on individual perpetrators.

“Action needs to be taken against everyone involved, from those who sell access to these girls to the buyers and networks that allow this exploitation to thrive,” she said.

Kenya’s legal response is fragmented and has substantive gaps especially in regards to adults. However, it is sufficient in children protection, specific offences cover trafficking, people living off or controlling someone through exploitation for prostitution, which "papasa" entails.