Emmy Kosgei Slams Hypocritical Nairobi Pastors for Secret Nightlife

Gospel musician Emmy Kosgei has spoken out against what she describes as hypocrisy within sections of the church, accusing some pastors in Nairobi of living double lives that contradict the messages they preach from the pulpit.

Tusker rally past Ulinzi to reach FKF Cup semifinals as Nairobi United bow out Football

Red hot Omanyala to orchestrate Kenya's 4x100m charge at World Relays today Athletics

Speaking during a recent public forum and in media interviews, the award-winning singer claimed that some well-known pastors publicly promote moral uprightness while privately engaging in behaviour they openly condemn.

“They are preaching water but drinking wine,” Kosgei said, using the phrase to describe what she views as a gap between public teaching and private conduct.

Claims of Secret Nightlife

Kosgei alleged that some pastors regularly frequent bars and nightclubs in Nairobi, sometimes in the company of women from their own congregations.

She said these activities often happen discreetly, away from church settings, making them difficult for followers to question or challenge.

According to the musician, the alleged behaviour has contributed to disillusionment among believers, particularly young Christians who look up to church leaders for guidance and moral direction.

“What happens in the dark eventually comes to light,” she added, warning that hidden actions can undermine the credibility of church leadership.

Call for Accountability

Kosgei emphasised that her remarks were not aimed at the entire clergy, but at individuals she believes misuse their positions of influence. She called for greater accountability within churches, arguing that spiritual leaders should be held to the same standards they expect from their followers.

She also encouraged congregants to rely on personal faith rather than blindly idolising religious leaders.

ALSO READ: Marion Naipei Finds Salvation: Inside Her 1st Service at Kanyari’s Church

Reaction and Wider Debate

Kosgei’s remarks have sparked debate on social media, with supporters praising her for speaking openly, while critics argue that such claims should be handled privately to avoid damaging the church’s image.

No specific pastors were named in her statements, and there has been no official response from church bodies regarding the claims at the time of publication.

Kosgei maintains that her intention is not to attack the church but to encourage honesty, repentance, and consistency between faith and conduct.