Psychologists Suggest Alternatives to Corporal Punishment for Gen Z

A controversial statement by an area chief in Uthiru has reignited a heated debate on how to discipline young people.

The chief, during a recent meeting, insisted that "Corporal punishment should be brought back. Gen Zs have become lazy, all they do is smoke bhang and chant wantam."

The remark immediately sparked discussions both online and offline, with many Kenyans weighing in on whether physical punishment is the solution to curbing indiscipline among the youth.

The Case Against the Cane

While the chief’s frustrations echo a familiar concern about changing times, psychologists warn that corporal punishment is an outdated and harmful tool.

Dr. Joyce Wanjiku*, a child and adolescent psychologist, says that physical discipline often creates fear and resentment rather than long-term behavioral change.

"Gen Zs are growing up in a digital and highly expressive world. They don’t respond well to intimidation or violence," she explains. "What they need is mentorship, emotional guidance, and clear boundaries that help them understand consequences."

A Broader Social Issue

Experts argue that today’s youth are more vocal about their rights and mental health, making alternative correction methods not just preferable but necessary.

Read More: Teens Home For Holidays: Handling Emotional Outbursts Without Loosing Your Cool

Dr. Wanjiku* adds that while some behaviors—such as substance use or disregard for authority—may worry adults, punishing physically often pushes young people further away.

Instead, she advocates for approaches such as: Restorative Justice, where young people take responsibility for their actions by making amends; Mentorship Programs, which pair youth with role models who can guide them through tough choices; and Counseling and Rehabilitation for cases involving drugs or other destructive habits.

The debate is not just about discipline but also about the environments shaping Gen Z.

Many experts point to unemployment, peer influence, and a lack of strong community support systems as contributors to the challenges young people face today.

"If we only see Gen Z as lazy or rebellious, we miss the bigger picture,”

Dr. Wanjiku* notes. “They need to be engaged in conversations, skill-building, and opportunities.

Discipline alone won’t solve structural problems.”