Victoria Kimani Defends Tyla’s Grammy Win Amid Debate on Who Consumes Her Music

South African singer Tyla has made history by securing her second career Grammy award. The 24-year-old artist won the prize for Best African Music Performance with her song "Push 2 Start."

She successfully edged out major industry names, including Nigerian stars Burna Boy, Davido, and Ayra Starr, as well as Ugandan singer Eddy Kenzo.

While the win sparked celebrations in South Africa, it also triggered a wave of criticism from some quarters. Critics on social media argued that the result felt like favouritism.

Some suggested the song was tailored for an American audience rather than an African one.

Kimani Challenges the "Monolith" Narrative

Kenyan singer Victoria Kimani has now stepped forward to defend Tyla against these claims. Writing on her Instagram stories the day after the ceremony, Kimani hit back at the idea that there is only one "true" African sound.

She asserted that the continent's people are diverse in both appearance and musical expression.

"Africans are NOT a monolith. We look & sound very different."

Kimani praised Tyla and her team for "breaking down walls." She noted that these barriers are often set by other Africans who do not recognise artists singing outside of specific dialects.

Personal Experience with Genre Pushback

The Kenyan star revealed that she has faced similar hurdles during her own career. Kimani, who has released five albums to date, stated she has been fusing African music with Pop and R&B for over a decade.

ALSO READ: Fela Kuti Makes History as First African to Receive Grammys Lifetime Achievement Award

“Africans like me. Who have been fusing African music with Pop & R&B (Afropop) for over a decade (5 Albums in FYI).”

She shared that she frequently receives comments telling her to "Sing in Swahili" or claiming her music "doesn’t sound Kenyan."

According to Kimani, the pushback Tyla is receiving for her Grammy win mirrors the resistance she faces whenever she releases new material.

"Finally, we have someone who went over all y’all heads. And I love to see it."

A Growing Cultural Debate

The debate highlights a deeper tension within the continent’s music scene. Tyla’s victory left many Nigerian music lovers disappointed, especially given the global dominance of Afrobeats.

Despite several nominations, no Nigerian stars took home a trophy in the African categories this year.

However, Kimani criticised the inconsistency of the critics. She suggested that some people choose when to claim their African identity while simultaneously "worshipping" foreign trends.

Despite the online friction, Tyla expressed immense pride in her heritage during her acceptance speech in Los Angeles. She described the moment as "insane" and stated she was excited to see more African representation on the global stage.

While some fans on social media conceded that she "deserved it," the conversation regarding African musical identity continues to trend across the continent.